The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Quality of eyeshadows is just as good as products that are twice the price. Fortunately, I walked away with minimal damage (antibiotics for a week and skip contacts for a few days), so I consider myself lucky and definitely think getting to the doctor sooner (about two hours) was the right move! Ive been wearing heavy eye makeup for over 15 years, and this is the first time Ive gone to an eye doctor because something was stuck in my eye. the use of . I have never been dissatisfied and will forever support ColourPop cosmetics. Want amazing offers and news on the latest consumer brands? In addition to refreshing your tired-looking eyes, No Filter ColourPop Concealer masks large pores, age spots, camouflage dark circles, and other blemishes visible on your skin with just one swipe. I guess Ive been living under a rock because Im 43 and just discovered them. Thank you! ? This ColourPop concealer review also found that it was created with soft blurring pigments to allow for a crease-proof, matte finish, meaning that you do not need a filter. These are still non-permitted color additives in eye-area use cosmetics. Outstanding piece, Christine. Phyrra tried to figure it all out in July 2012, list of FDA-approved Color Additives here, Safety Assessment of Modified Terephthalate Polymers as Used in Cosmetics, April 12, 2013, CosIng database results here for borosilicate glasses, CosIng database results for synthetic fluorphlogopite here, https://ecostardust.com/pages/non-bioglitter-amnesty, https://www.fatherly.com/news/glitter-is-destroying-the-environment-scientists-ban/. With regards to biodegradable glitters (and PET etc for that matter) I hope the FDA will assess the safety of ingesting them in small quantities. My goal was to do more research and present that information to readers and consumers so that they can make the best decision for themselves with more information as more brands add plastic glitter to their products (with or without warnings). Combination skin. Register. Im not looking for sympathy (I knew the risks), but it did make me want to look into glitter in cosmetics again (previous attempts to find clarity were not fruitful it was not much more fruitful this time). I guess I've been living under a rock because I'm 43 and just discovered them. Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice. I hope youre feeling better now! Colourpop Creme Gel Liner, Exit Liner LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Brow Precision Pencil, Black n' Brown LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Ultra Matted Lip, Melonade LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Brow Precision Pencil, Dope Taupe LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop As such, you will not develop dry skin, acne, or rash when you use ColourPop products because they are free of toxic and dangerous chemicals. I do think though that I want to avoid borosilicate in my eye products. You use the contact page on their website and describe the issue you are experiencing. One can get an allergic reaction such as swollen eyelids," adding that if a lip product has been used on your lips it may carry contamination, which could lead to a multitude of eye issues. My BFF is an makeup freak, biochemist, and an ophthalmologist MD. Alternative ingredients need to be used. I need information please. So it's probably not a good idea to use lip liner on your eyes. Made in the USA, we imagine, innovate, test, and manufacture all under one roof. Normal skin. Both of the CIR reports seem to confirm safety based on present practices of use and concentration by the industry; the tone of the report on PET glitter read to me that they were trying to establish its safety. All you have to do is customize your routine and create your look. I was very happy with the smooth order experience, fast shipping, and careful packaging of items in glass bottles to prevent breakage. Dry skin. They don't test finished products or ingredients on animals, and neither do their suppliers or any third-parties. Since this post was really focused on potential for eye irritation/injury, I focused on eye products (as those are also where the warnings apply, if they exist), but I know I will be exercising more caution in the removal process if I was wearing a very glittery highlighter/blush color! Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews. Long time reader now subscribed. for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't There are some of U.S. cosmetics are actually banned in other countries due to their ingredients, like formaldehyde. Eyelash Glue. Furthermore, this concealer contains plankton extract, a versatile skincare ingredient that protects your skin from blue light and UV radiation, helps prevent toxins and pollutants from penetrating your skin, and reduces oxidative stress. There doesnt seem to be a way for consumers to determine if product A with a warning of not intended for use around the immediate eye area is actually any riskier than product B that calls itself an eyeshadow with no warning. I dont know if it would make much difference to dry eyes (doubtfully), but worth looking into. Is Colourpop breaking the law? While doing our ColourPop review, we checked some of the products they offer to see how safe they are, the ingredients they use to create them, and who should use them. Many cosmetics companies rely on consumer ignorance about potential hazards. Create clean lines and prevent feathering disasters with ColourPop's long-wearing and super pigmented Lippie Pencil liner, designed to be worn under your fave matching lip color. What are the dangers of using this product around the eyes? Maybe it behooves those who buy Colour Pop (since they seem to be including these more and more) and other brands using these ingredients to write directly to the company explaining that they wont be buying palettes or single shadows that contain these. Turns out you should never, ever use a lip liner as an eyeliner. Contacted customer service and they would not send it to me even though it was in stock and available and after repeating myself countless times asking why I was unable to get the pallet I gave up. Its renewed my love of makeup and reawakened my interest in playing with different looks and color. When it comes to one of the popular TikTok trendof using lip liner as eyeliner, one that got over 4 million views, it looks great but just how safe is it? First of all Im glad your eye is ok. Second being a former contact lens wearer I know the perils of not getting anything in your eye! Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to Yes, I read it that way, too or at the very least, it certainly seemed like the merest fine print was not a 100% sure-fire way to avoid liability. As an older woman I admittedly dont find a whole lot of makeup items on their website that I can use, but I appreciate the quality of what I do get. Nothing quite like having an up close and personal run-in with PET glitter to cause one to look deeper into its potential hazards! MAC would also be a safe bet solely because of the overall solid quality and variety of products. I'm worried because nobody informs me anything, not even the carrier. Ive bookmarked it for future reference too. Light, Neutral undertones. Youre lucky to live there, enjoy! By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I dont often wear glitter on my eyes because its so difficult to take off throughly enough, but if and when I decide to, I am sure this will be a huge help. Youre an absolute pearl. I think if enough people did and the companies understood clearly just how much business they might be losing, things might change. The Fenty Rose (4) and Smoky (6) eyeshadow palettes both contain glitter shades, which have PET glitter in them, but they are listed as eyeshadows with an eye icon on the back of the palette with no disclosure or warning on either the cardboard packaging or the actual palette that I could find. Thats what kind of scared me the most about it. Of the seven products tested, the only one that was noted as having any adverse event reported contained 46.272% of PET glitter with no size indicated; the other six products ranged between 8 and 12% concentration with three that provided size used and three that did not provide a size. I occasionally get into researching about something thoroughly like you do (I chuckled with empathy at your reply to kjh The hours Ive spent with my eyes almost glazed over and two separate windows with 30-40 tabs open in each for the last three days trying to find clarity), but your results and conclusions (so thoughtfully and eloquently put) helps thousands of women and I commend you for that! and I had to pay custom fees over the price of the products without the discountplus, it was missing an item. (If youre so inclined, you can click here to review the FDAs color additive list for yourself.). Mascara. Lastly, the brand offers a plethora of safe payment methods, allowing you to choose the option you prefer. There are two primary concerns that I routinely see from consumers in the online beauty community and from readers with respect to glitter: 1) whether cosmetic-grade glitter is eye safe, and 2) concerns about plastic glitter and its impact on the environment. We're here to help you make better beauty purchases that you'll enjoy and love! Other Eye Makeup. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. It would be great if the world was kind and thoughtful, but it isnt. Login Regarding the Borosilicate, I find it in three PM Decadence shades (likely the very three that I hate using because they feel gritty: Enigma, Sinful and Gold Standard); two ABH Sultry shades (Rose Quartz and Cinder) and one ColourPop Brown Sugar shade (Saute). Its inexpensive but very high quality which means I can and do buy everything I want! Shipping 60. Trustpilot gave ColourPop a 3.9-average score out of 38,786, with the majority of consumers saying that they love the fact that their products are affordable, effective, cruelty-free, and easy to use. and our Lip Primer. It might also be something where if the first ingredient contains it then that might be more bothersome vs. deeper on the list! Minor scratches can heal in a few days, whereas deeper ones can take longer, so seeing an eye doctor will allow them to look at the area and prescribe any necessary medications or provide treatment instructions for that specific case. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our The company ships within 3 to 5 business days, but this may take longer if they have a new launch or some crazy promotion. Normal-to-Dry skin. I try to ignore the pressed glitters in my Colourpop palettes but it would be better if they werent in there at all. You made my brain hurt reading this. Your eyes never look irritated in your photos, and Ive often wondered how you use and remove so much makeup every day with seemingly no eye or skin irritation. It goes against our guidelines to offer incentives for reviews. Fellow blogger Phyrra tried to figure it all out in July 2012, and she corresponded with FDA, who said that Glitter usually consists of aluminum, an approved color additive, bonded to an etched plastic film composed of polyethylene terephthalate. The 100%-vegan-and-cruelty-free formula consists of marine ingredients that hydrate and protect your delicate under eyes. BUT, according to the FDA, None of these colors may be used in products that are for use in the area of the eye unless otherwise indicated. I dont see any indication to the contrary so it looks like these two lakes are NOT allowed in products to be used around the eye. Awesomely comprehensive research and thanks for your personal input. Dry skin. Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! Which is why Im so pleased that Christine put this post out. As an emollient, the Ethylhexyl Palmitate that this product feature helps keep your skin moist and supple by decreasing the loss of water from the top layers of your skin. And disappointment. In 2009, MAC glitters came with this warning: Keep entirely clear of eye area. Others love their packaging and excellent customer support service because they are responsive and resolve issues swiftly. All rights reserved. View Privacy Policy. ColourPop has a rating of 2.25 stars from 325 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and theyll be displayed as long as an account is active. , As an eye care professional, I would like to say thank you from my heart for this! Based in Los Angeles, California, ColourPop is a cosmetics brand that makes products for the face, lips, and eyes. Colourpop ColourPop PEACH FUZZ Matte Eyeliner Retractable Pencil Creme Gel (Pastel Peach), 0.2g (0.007 Ounce) 1 Count (Pack of 1) 4.1 out of 5 stars 61. . Service 61. Fixed that, thank you! Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! However, it became a bigger issue when I discovered that Im allergic to synthetic mica. I think pressed glitter should be sold at least separately, if brand wants to include that in their range. It aims to provide healthier cosmetics products with significantly fewer chemicals to save the animals and promote positive change in the beauty industry. Get started with ColourPop today and find your favorite cruelty-free cosmetics products. Lip Liner. Hyaluronic acid can also help lessen the redness and visible appearance of acne and protect your skin, which is helpful for acne-prone skin. Even though theres not a clear answer, the information is very helpful. Where can I purchase Colourpop products and how can I be sure that Colourpop products are real? Under Conclusion or Confusionthe first sentence regarding the FDAs positionare you missing a word there? COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lip Liner, Lip Pencil, Creamy, In the Nude, 0.012 Fl Oz ,Lip Crayon, Lip Makeup, Intense Pigmentation, Self-Sharpening Pencil, Easy Application, Instant Definition 4.4 4.4 out of 5 stars (1,072) Normal-to-Dry skin. Colourpop You're The Bestie Lippie Pencil Vault Set $38.99 New ColourPop 10 Pieces Lippie Stix Vault Bestie in show $39.99 New All Auction Buy It Now Best Match 120 Results Brand: ColourPop Formulation Buying Format All Filters SPONSORED ColourPop Lippie Pencil Liners Matte Vegan Vault Cruelty-Free Warms Cools NWOB $8.79 to $13.79 SPONSORED Normal-to-Dry skin. Ive really only looked at finished cosmetics vs. raw ingredients, and it seems to turn up as polyethylene terephthalate. The quality of the makeup is fantastic!I'm so impressed with the color options and the overall visual beauty of the products. Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. Whatever goes on my face is going near my eyes, too, but I dont use anything specifically for my eyes . I would've snagged . I wrote to you by email and they told me that it would arrive soon and eight more days have passed. Sign up for our daily send to get the latest beauty news and product launches. While I dont feel any personal need to be using large glitter on my eyes, Im thankful for your research into this. I got my item quick and easy since it was my first-time ordering form Colourpop. Created with Sketch. I think its one thing for a brand to sell individual pressed or loose glitter as a standalone product, but when a brand includes them in a premade eyeshadow palette, it seems like theyre endorsing their consumers to use the glitter on their eyes, even if theres language on the box warning against it not being intended for that use. contact us! I love Colourpop eyeshadow palettes, and eye makeup! Glad I normally prefer satin or matte finishes anyway. Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. I will say that the Ambient Lighting products are very finely milled, and while its used on the face, some people use highlighters (including me at times) as a highlight in the inner corner of the eye, or as an eyeshadow. As far as the FDA is concerned, none of it is approved. This is very important to me! The ultimate dreamy collection full of lavenders and violets , for soft and naturally defined lashes, this is your go-to black mascara, add a touch of definition with our newest brown mascara, A dreamy lavender palette full of serene shades , Be an angel with this bright silvery lavender with silver pin points , Glow on with this soft silvery cool-toned lavender, A true pinky lavender with pink, silver, teal & violet pin points , Swipe on this soft silvery lavender with silver, pink & violet pin points , Supercharged metallic vivid violet with a blue duo chrome flip! I know it might be annoying, and people want many colors and finishes in one pallette it seems these days, but then the time something DOES gosh forbid happen, its scarywhom would want to go blind over an eyeshadow look?! In fact, the ingredients in lip liner can make it dangerous to use as eyeliner, especially if you don't take the proper precautions to disinfect it with an alcohol-based cleanser, per Allure. Rare Beauty Warm Wishes Effortless Bronzer Stick Swatches, Sephora Collection Colorful Blushes Swatches (2023), elf Halo Glow Contour, Highlight, Blush Beauty Wand Swatches, A Pink & Plum Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, A Tropical Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, ColourPop x Harry Potter Collection Yer a Disappointment, ColourPop. The Brella SweatControl Patch could be a game-changer for anyone with hyperhidrosis. Eye Makeup Remover. In part of its findings, CIR wrote that a lack of case reports and no ongoing FDA regulatory actions suggested to the Panel that ocular injury is not likely. If, in fact, consumers sustain ocular injury from the use of PET glitter, then it seems it will fall to consumers to report those injuries to the FDA. Can you really use a lip liner to create an eye look? She passed on the following info re colourpop eyeshadow. If any professional makeup artists are using craft glitter on other people thats a real problem, much bigger than PET glitter. I like that they let me know about my order; I really appreciate the use of DHL. FWIW, she thinks very highly of the Beauty Brains scientists, and their blog and podcast. As a person who has problems with my eyes, I steer very, very clear of any glitter whatsoever. Thats why we spend quite a bit of time in Vegas, and we usually drive down the coast at least once a year through San Fran, love Cali! http://thebeautybrains.com/2015/12/should-you-buy-organic-botox-from-kim-kardashian-episode-113/. Redefining luxury beauty by creating high quality products at affordable prices. The website saysFor maximum coverage: Use fingertip and tap shadow onto EYE liduse a flat synthetic brushthroughout the crease of the EYE and finally, ***not intended for the eye area. Also, Urban Decay Moondust shadows are in the same category of risk when worn on the eye as say MAC glitter? Im happy to get cruelty-free, vegan products at a reasonable price.I was told about this company by my then teenage daughter. Also, I hope youre healing well. I fangirl when I see you turning on law school mode. no glitter is eye safe. Some color additives, when used in combination, may form new pigments, which may not be approved for the intended use. Im sorry about your experience but am glad that there was no permanent damage. Palettes were amazing, packaging was great, and the deal was amazing! Your California Privacy Rights. In my quest to try and to provide information to readers, I considered looking to ophthalmologists, who would likely be the ones seeing the impacts of glitter. Subscribe to our weekly newsletter. I have been using the colourpop foundation gor several years. I did find the top references to it as a craft glitter. Hi Christine have been reading up about ingredients diligently ever since I discovered this post. That means you do not have to break the bank to enhance your appearance and boost your self-esteem using their products. In terms of colors, a nude lip liner in a neutral hue close to the natural shade of your lips is good to have on hand, while a lip liner in brown gives you that nostalgic '90s look. If you accidentally stab yourself in the eye with a mascara wand or eye brush that could cause damage to the eye. More safety and environmental regulations have been removed in the U.S. over the past couple of years. And Ive seen them wind up on my waterline or tear duct from exactly that! It also protects the cells and fights those unwanted signs of premature skin aging. Duplicate a high-end product or never buy the same shade twice. That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. 7. Colourpop's Ultra Matte Lips retail at $6.00 USD for 0.11 oz., just a fraction of the cost of their high-end counterparts. Also, dont use craft glitter in place of cosmetic-grade glitter! Then soak my lashes with an additional cotton pad to get rid of the mascara. They even caution against using a lip liner, or any makeup product not intended to be near your eyeball, in that general vicinity (you can read their eye-cosmetics safety guidelines here). Consumers will have to look at the information available and use their own judgment about what is comfortable for them. These ColourPop lip liners are absolutely amazing. Yes. This list is useful in particular for anyone who is concerned about Pressed Pigments (not glitter) as you can look up the various pigments used in a particular shade to see if it is approved for eye usage or not. Though these eyeliners cost just $7 a tube, ColourPop's creamy consistency rivals even the most high-end eyeliners. I feel like acknowledging PET glitter safety/legality as a gray area is a bit taboo, and its wonderful to read a thoughtful breakdown of the different kinds too! Thank you for sharing the current status quo with us! I am no chemist, but find my science degree comes in handy with these glitter discussions;). FDA considers glitter and mica-based composite pigments to be non-permitted color additives when used in FDA-regulated products, including cosmetics. You might inquire with the brand to see if they have a more detailed ingredient list. Shop Now, Free International Shipping on orders over. ), so Im glad Lit listed those measurements so we can have some visual idea of various particle sizes. Thank you so much for this thorough and fantastically researched overview! Ad Choices. Oh my god!! Body Art. . Almost all the products that ColourPop Cosmetics offers are vegan, meaning that they do not include animal-derived ingredients. The U.S. pales in comparison of other countries. 2023 Cond Nast. Im sure it was a scary moment. Once the enforcement discretion period is over, FDA will resume our enforcement of these non-permitted colors.. Im glad your eye was okay !! Now its fairly ubiquitous. For US consumers, you can report cosmetic-related complaints to the FDA. Cookie Notice All glitter products are not eye safe. . Based on reading through all three reports, the final report on PET glitter didnt seem quite as detailed or as thorough to me, so Id certainly like to see more studies/tests done. Colorpop shipped me my order timely and accurately, and the items that I ordered arrived in perfect condition. However, in looking at your list above and running the ingredients through my database, I see that PET is in quite a few highlighters (I know, not used on eyes, but still, interesting as I wonder if these products can scratch the face) and in one eyebrow product, Fenty MVP pencil. Products like Stilas Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows contain plastic glitter in several shades and classic Urban Decay Eyeshadows (seems like most that were described as having micro-glitter) like Chopper, Gunmetal, and Midnight Cowboy (not an exhaustive list) also used PET glitter. Shop our blackest black, colorful, matte & metallic gel eye liners, liquid liners, and eyeliner pencils. Glitters are not eye safe and it drives me nuts when I see companies (like ColourPop) put glitters in eyeshadow palettes especially ones that are aimed at more juvenile customers. Baby Lotion. I keep seeing mixed signals from indie brands on how safe any glitter is. . shop the collection, Get more time to pay with Klarna! In 2012, the FDA had replied to another media outlet with this: However, we are exercising enforcement discretion for a period of time. The follow-up question is also what is the definition of safe because CIR says ocular injury is not likely but does, ultimately, say PET glitter is safe to use in eye cosmetics, so it seems safe is more of a spectrum of safety not that it is 100% safe. I reached out to the FDA via their online contact form on January 14th, 2020: I wanted to inquire whether glitter, Polyethylene Terephthalate, is an approved ingredient for eye cosmetics, such as eye liner, eye shadow, and so forth. Available in 4-grams bottles, this concealer features citric acid to help even your skin tone, brighten, soften, and make your skin smooth by targeting dark spots and pigmentation. Not sure where all the negative reviews came from. This is fascinating to me (although Im sorry you had to go through this). ColourPop Cosmetics products are cruelty-free, meaning that they are 100% animal-friendly, and the brand only tests them on human beings. being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Very Light, Olive, cool undertones. Because of my age (advanced) and problems Ive had with my eyes (retinal tears), this whole business of these non-eye-safe glitters is an important one to me but even younger people with healthy eyes well, a lot of them are concerned about this ongoing inclusion of these plastic based glitters in eye products. Hi Christine This is so confusing. A few customers did not like that ColourPop does not offer refunds and returns.